Our critics selected 32 of their favorite LI burgers, which battled it out, bracket-style. You voted, the pairings shrunk, and a winner reigned supreme.

Congrats to the Juicy Lucy from New York Burger Bar in Massapequa for capturing the popular vote!

Round 1 Results Round 2 Results Round 3 Results Round 4 Results

Round 5

Round 5 of 5
Time left to vote:

0%0 VOTES

Juicy Lucy at New York Burger Bar. VOTE

Juicy Lucy

NEW YORK BURGER BAR

4225 Merrick Rd.

Massapequa

516-799-9199

This burger comes stuffed with American cheese, topped with grilled red onion, tomato, pickle and a pink mayonnaise-based sauce.

READ MORE WEBSITE MAP IT YELP
VS

0%0 VOTES

The classic burger at All American Burger. VOTE

Classic burger

ALL AMERICAN BURGER

4286 Merrick Rd.

Massapequa

516-798-9574

For those who favor thin patties, grilled medium-well, this longstanding favorite fills the need.

READ MORE WEBSITE MAP IT YELP

share my vote

Interactive editor: Polly Higgins UX: Anthony Carrozzo, Matthew Cassella Development: Anja Kastl Production: Alison Bernicker, Saba Ali Reporters: Peter M. Giannotti, Erica Marcus, Joan Reminick Editor: Marjorie Robins Photo editor: Rebecca Cooney Copy editor: Peggy Brown

Comments

Newsday.com now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.