The best bagels on Long Island: Vote for your favorites

We've selected 31 notable bagel shops on Long Island. Now it's your turn. Vote on your favorites, and we'll crown two winners – one North Shore champion, one South Shore. Check back to see how your favorites are doing; voting goes through noon on Dec. 29. And if we left off your go-to place, note it in the comments section below.

Vote for your favorites in each category:

North Shore South Shore All
Time left to vote:
Lynbrook Bagels WINNERLynbrook Bagels



Comments now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.

You can only vote once for this item in .

Are you sure?